What does it mean to be free?
by Elouise

I used to think leaving home would set me free
No more eyes watching my every move
No more beatings meant to break my resistance
No more unwelcome talks about how I needed to change
No more books or surreptitious hints about
how to be a good Christian daughter or woman
All I had to do was stay ‘pure,’ get married, and leave home–
preferably far from my parents and their attempts
to make me into the woman I could never be
Early in our marriage I went back to school. First seminary, and later university. Before university, I traveled to Germany for five months of intensive German language study. I came home fluent. Even my dreams were auf Deutsch. Through all this, my husband, my children, and my piano held me together no matter where I was.
Sadly, this didn’t include staying connected to my sisters. A ‘small’ thing I thought didn’t matter.
Today, after Ruth’s recent death from congestive heart failure, plus Diane’s earlier death from ALS, I have one sister left on this earth. She’s my youngest sister, the one I scarcely knew when I married and left home. Thankfully, our lives crossed after I began teaching at the seminary in the 1980’s.
I used to think connections with my parents came first, though they were often painful. Today I know better. My relationship with each sister shaped me far more than my parents did, despite their efforts to turn me into a good girl/woman.
Diane and I found each other first, thanks to her willingness to talk with me about our childhood struggles with our parents. My youngest sister and I connected following the sudden death of her husband about ten years ago. I wish I could say that Sister #2 and I found each other before her death this past June. We talked on the phone from time to time and emailed each other about health issues. But we never felt fully at ease with each other.
Still, we were reaching out as adults. This went against everything our father tried to program in us. No talking or giggling with each other when the lights went out. No complaining to each other about family business. No secrets kept from our parents. Ever.
Instead, we were to smile, obey Daddy’s Rules for Good Girls, and show up every Sunday at church. Furthermore, if we had things to say to each other, we were to keep our parents in the “know” even after we’d married and moved far away from them and each other.
Thanks for listening, and for stopping by today.
Elouise♥
© Elouise Renich Fraser, 15 August 2023
Photo found at medium.com
I just read the Rules for Good Girls. I do hope what I’m saying doesn’t come across as patronizing. I am so struck by how you have worked to unlearn and release that conditioning. I have my own version, of course, so my celebration of your journey is heartfelt.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much for your comment, Jane. It took years to unlearn these things–not because I knew they were wrong, but because of that other word you use–“conditioning.” It was engrained so deeply that I thought other families without these rules were somehow wrong. The rules, plus the kind of isolation they created between us as sisters, did nothing to help me become an adult woman. Cheers to you, and to all women finding their way.
Elouise
LikeLike
This touches my heart.
I can relate to it.
Thank you for sharing your heart, Elouise!
You always have my (((HUGS))), ❤️ , and prayers 🙏
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re so welcome! I love your (((HUGS))) and am grateful for your prayers.
Elouise
LikeLiked by 1 person
Each day is a journey…we live, we learn, we grow. 🙂 This Mandela quote has always been meaningful to me…
“For to be free is not merely to cast off one’s chains, but to live in a way that respects and enhances the freedom of others.” – Nelson Mandela 🙂 ❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
What a wonderful quote! So true and so very difficult to live into.
Thanks to you and to Nelson Mandela for this challenging truth.
Elouise
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, difficult. But a worthy goal. ❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Elouise!
I have stumbled upon a question that was moved to back burner for sometime but keeps popping up. Perhaps you have some insight.
Question When did the terminology “The Fall” begin ? I don’t think it is in the Hebrew scripture and the concept of disobedience seems to be something Paul talks about in Roman’s 5:15. But I am not sure The Fall is a helpful term.
I think Agustine spends quite sometime working through sin and ultimately naming it as “The Fall”, and artists depict the Fall pre and post Agustine by moving the serpent from climbing up the Tree of knowledge to a fallen slivering creature crawling through the dust of the earth.
My stumbling block is that when people Fall physically often it is internalized as having done something wrong spiritually then embarrassment begins leading to fear and fear leads to defeat and lack of motivation and reduces resilience. Those who have fallen begin to fear and isolation often occurs. Then opportunities are reduced causing a decline in resilience. I feel like the internalization of The Fall has done great psychological damage.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi, Dave. I’m sorry to be slow responding to your thought-provoking comment. Have you read Wikipedia’s article on this?
Here’s the link, should you be interested in doing so. It’s quite comprehensive (bringing in numerous ways of describing “the Fall”). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_man#:~:text=The%20fall%20of%20man%2C%20the,Genesis%2C%20chapters%201%E2%80%933.
When I read their various ways of interpreting the Fall, I couldn’t help seeing this has often been used to put women in their place, making them accountable for whatever happens to them. Not good interpretation!
However, I also like your take on the way a physical fall can become an open door to the idea that something must be wrong with me (because I fell) and must now live with the consequences. My “fall” when I broke my jaw 8 years ago had an incredibly bad impact on my sense of self. It didn’t matter that there were reasons for the fall. What mattered was that I fell at all. And yes, I would even say it had a psychological impact that included shame (not just pain, for example). Plus…weeks and months of incredibly difficult healing that never quite got back to my ‘normal.’
Thanks for the question! I pray all is going as well as possible with you just now. These are difficult times, especially for those with health issues.
Elouise
LikeLike
Elouise. I appreciate your response. Do you think Agustine coined the term “The Fall”. And if so, why was his description of original sin as “The Fall”
accepted by so wide of an audience. The term seems to have stuck without much challenge to it.
I was surprised the way even artists seemed to have been taken by the term. I will reread Wikpedia to try to glean more out of that article. Thanks again.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Extra ❤️, (((HUGS))), and prayers for you. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you from the bottom of my heart. Praying you’re taking care of yourself these days.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Can you believe it’s September already?
Keep praying for me. I have some important med visits coming up.
(((HUGS))) ❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes! 🙏🏻💜💕
LikeLiked by 1 person
Miss you around here.
Hope all is well.
Continued prayers and love!
(((HUGS))) ❤️❤️❤️
LikeLike
Oh…I wish I knew more about what it means to be ‘old’! Thank you for your prayers and notes. I’m most grateful.
Elouise
LikeLiked by 1 person