Three Days, Three Quotes Challenge | Day 3
by Elouise
Women will always fear war more than men because they are mothers.
A woman will always have a baby, her own or her children’s in her arms.
She will always be tormented by fear for her children,
the fear that one day she might be a witness to their own deaths.
Natalya Baranskaya, Russian Writer
It’s easy to think that in the USA we don’t have a long history of overt warfare. We do, however, have a history of covert warfare that is traumatic for those living with it daily on the streets, at home, in prisons, or in places of employment.
I recently began following Fiction & Development, a blog that uses fictional literary works to discover and highlight international development issues. I’ve linked to their recent review of selected literary works about women and children during times of war.
The reviewer points out that protection of women and children has often been used as a propaganda tool to persuade citizens to support war efforts. To this I would add, to persuade citizens to vote for this or that politician. Look at the box of quotes (not fictional) at the end of the review to see how world leaders have done this in recent years.
What woman or child doesn’t want safety? How does one vote against propaganda that assumes wartime creates lack of safety for women and children, or that going to war will make things safer for ‘our’ women and children? Put another way, how does one vote for the reality that all women and children are vulnerable at any time, and that the rhetoric of war denies this truth?
* * *
Thanks to my blogging friend Herminia for inviting me to take part in this challenge! If you don’t know her already, check out her blog. Herminia is a go-getter. She doesn’t waste time or words. Every post is short and to the point.
Here are the rules for this challenge:
- Post one quote a day for 3 days (your quote or someone else’s)
- Thank and create a link to the blogger who nominated you
- Nominate 3 other bloggers (per post) to take part in the challenge
Here are my last three nominees:
- You! Are you still sitting on the fence, wavering? Just do it!
- Mum C Writes
- Verseherder
No Rush and No Obligation ~ You don’t have to report in to anyone!
© Elouise Renich Fraser, 29 Sept 2015
Photo credit: Arkady Shaikhet, 1942, found at pinterest.com
Hi Elouise, Doug and I spent two weeks in Russia at the end of the summer. If you can believe it, the picture of the ‘underground bomb shelter’ is actually a subway station in Moscow. I think in English it’s called, “Mayakovskaya” station. Not only this one but many are quite elaborate with paintings, sculptures, vaulted ceilings, and lots of marble! And, by the way, the system is very easy to use (and clean!!) making much of Moscow accessible. Thought you’d be interested. Beth
PS. I’m reading “Leningrad: Siege and Symphony” by Brian Moynahan which follows Dmitri Shostakovich and the arts community during the seige and many of the details of that time of June, 1942 to January, 1944. I don’t think it’s that well written, but the information is fascinating and frightening. It includes much about the Stalin era pre-WW2 as well, which was no less brutalizing.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Beth, Thanks for this great comment! The photo came with the caption but without explanation. I’ve been wondering where the shelter was–especially given its grandeur. I wonder when the subway stations were constructed. I’m also interested in the book you’re reading–because its focused on the arts community, and because it covers the period of history into which I was born. Two weeks in Russia? I’m trying very hard not to be jealous or envious or any of those other awful things.
Elouise
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t know when they were constructed, but I am aware that Stalin authorized many public works projects in the 30’s, including the waterway project linking Moscow and Leningrad (now St. Petersburg). Of course, he didn’t care what the cost was to the thousands of workers conscripted for them… Speaking of traveling, I’ve loved your observations about all you saw in Scotland. I’m enviously looking at travels there and through the UK…Isn’t it great we can share our experiences?
LikeLike
I read your quotation of Natalya Baranskaya, and followed your link to Fiction & Development, and both gave me much to ponder. I conclude that not much will change until:
a. Men learn to take as much responsibility for love and care of their children as women do, especially in time of war
b: Nations learn to solve their differences by non-violent means.
Our president has been trying to use diplomacy, though not very successfully. There are still too many people who believe that force is the only way to solve problems between nations and ideologies..
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you, Waldo, for this thoughtful comment. I especially appreciate your point about men. Force seems to be both inevitable and “manly.” A deadly combination.
Elouise
LikeLike
Thanks for reading up on Fiction&Development! You’re welcome.
LikeLike
Thanks for your comment. And come visit anytime!
Elouise
LikeLike
in the USA we don’t have a long history of overt warfare. What the earthe do you mean??????? The American Civil War must go down as one of the most horrendous wars ever. Both side spoke the same language, both had the same religious foundation and there were brothers and sons and daughters on both sides.?? I just don’t understand.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Dear John, Thanks for your questions. From my perspective, the overt American Civil War has morphed into a long-term covert war. We’ve gone from using an iron fist (the Civil War) to a velvet glove (via politics and other ways of asserting power over others). Yes, there was open warfare during the Civil War–and also against American Indians, for example. But now we’ve become skilled at waging and ignoring underground warfare that simply continues the patterns of the past. We haven’t (since Pearl Harbor) had bombings and other forms of overt warfare that are well-known in other parts of the world. Now it’s what happens under the cover of home life, work life, prison life, homeless life. The point is that women and children are the largest losers in either scenario.
Elouise
LikeLike
Yes.How true and our war against women and migrants is bad here as well.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Waldo – there are a lot of men who care a lot more for their children than their mothers. But maybe your generalization is correct.
But I thought we were quoting…. I have had no internet for three days here in Africa and so I lob my quote late. Maybe out of court.
“It is only with the heart that one can see clearly, for the most essential things are invisible to the eye.” – Antonie de Sainte Exupery
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi, Robin.
Thanks for this response to Waldo. I don’t know whether he’ll see it right away. No matter. Thank you.
I love this quote and The Little Prince! Thanks for sending it. No need to apologize for anything–I’m happy to hear from you whenever you’re able.
Elouise
LikeLike
Thank you so much Elouise for reading and linking http://fictioningdevelopment.org I am pleased you find the reviews instructive. I agree with the thinking here, I find change and development a difficult concept. It is the propaganda and hypocrisy that goes with this that tires me. I will keep reading yours.
LikeLike